My dilemna on which Sandy's Pizza Deal to Pick: 50% vs. 45% off

There are two Sandy's Pizza deal both with different combos.  Can't decide on which to pick...  Let me show my rationalization.

Deal 1: 50% Off: P465 instead of P935 for 14 Inch Supersize Pizza, Large Pasta and Mouthwatering Buffalo Chicken Wings from Sandy's Pizza
click logo to go to deal                             
  • Delicious hand-tossed pizzas
  • Unique menu offering a wide range of Italian and American choices
  • Relaxing atmosphere inside of the restaurant
  • With this special treat package good for 6 people you will enjoy any 14" supersize pizza, large pasta and buffalo chicken wings  for P465 instead of P935
  • This feast combo will ensure that your stomach‘s satisfied baritone grumblings will harmonize with your palate’s angelic falsetto
The fine print
  • Voucher validity: June 11, 2011 until Dec. 11, 2011
  • Valid for all 3 branches (Makati, QC, San Juan)
  • Valid for dine-in, take-out and deliver (for delivery, additional charge of P99 applies)
  • Price is Net (includes service charge and VAT)
  • Voucher is transferable and can be given as gift to family and friends
  • Buy as many vouchers as you want
Deal 2: Up to 45% OFF! Only P450 For Any 18-inch Pizza + some delicious Buffalo Chicken Wings at Sandy’s Pizza! Choose among 3 locations!

click logo to go to deal
  • Enjoy some Homemade Real New York-Style Thin Crust Pizza.
  • Choose among 16 awesome flavors, including some unique Filipino-inspired selections.
  • You've got 3 delicious flavors of chicken wings to choose from.
  • You can choose for dine-in or take out. Option for delivery.
  • Pick up any of the 3 perfect locations : Katipunan, San Juan or Makati.
The Deal's Terms
  • Valid from June 24 to September 30, 2011.
  • Add P99 for delivery.
  • Call in advance for multiple orders.
  • Maximum of 3 vouchers per transaction per person.
  • Not valid with other offers.
  • See universal fine print.
Both deals are:
  • Valid for 3 locations
Makati Branch:

Riverfront Building JP Rizal cor. Villena St. (Behind Rockwell), Makati

QC Branch:

154 Katipunan Ave. (Hernandez Bldg.), White Plains, Quezon City

San Juan Branch:

683 J. Abad Santos St., Little Baguio, San Juan

General phone line:

(02) 721-8334 / (02) 721-8329

  • Allows delivery but with 99 php charge
  • Deal 1: 14" supersize pizza (480 php 1 flavor/520 php if sampler), large pasta (195 php) and buffalo chicken wings (220 php) = up to 50% off at 465 php
  • Deal 2: 18" pizza (590 php 1 flavor/645 php if sampler) + buffalo wings (220 php) = up to 45% at 450 php

        Both deals look good.

  • If you love pizza you won't mind the 5% discount difference right?  
  • If you love pasta then you should choose the one with the pasta and have 5% more discount than the other deal.  
       So the question is to pick or not to pick the pasta?=)